The Company

The Mystery Theatre Unlimited Cast

Our current ensemble, frequent collaborators, and emeritus members

The Mystery Theatre Unlimited Company

Mystery Theatre Unlimited company group photo from 2016

Our current cast

Makayla Carney • Pete Fernbaugh • Dustin Heavilin • Butch Maxwell • Brendan Sheehan
Makayla CarneyPete FernbaughDustin HeavilinButch MaxwellBrendan Sheehan

Other members of our ensemble

Vera Barton-Maxwell • Sean Decker • Karissa Martin • Melody Meadows • Joel Nau • Renee Storm • Micah Underwood • Sadie Crow Varlas
Vera Barton-MaxwellSean DeckerKarissa MartinMelody MeadowsJoel NauRenee StormMicah UnderwoodSadie Crow Varlas

Emeritus Members

Gino Angelo (d) Vera Barton-Maxwell Cheryl Burke (d) Bert Furioli (d) Dee (McCorkle) Gregg Arlene Merryman Michael Moran Ryan Sears Frank Wilson

Others Who Have Appeared with the Company

Kathy Barton Larry Carlisle Katie Crosbie Josh DeBeni Kevin Dennis Jim Ellis Deborah Frazier P.D. Gregg (d) Jenn Kellner Muscar Mario Muscar Evan Oslund Michael Ramsay John Reilly Meghan Ross Gretchen Schneider Maura Schneider Rachel Podwika Thompson Valery Staskey Cheryl Violette
(d) indicates deceased member of the Mystery Theatre Unlimited family
Last updated: June 1, 2026