Pete Fernbaugh
Joined 2019 — Debuted in Slay Ride 2.
He has acted in many shows around the Ohio Valley, including Brook Hills Playhouse, Towngate Theatre and Stage Light Theatre. He also runs a different kind of mystery company: Cloak and Dagger.
Mystery Theatre Credits
As a principal:
- Frosty D. Snowman, Esq. — Slay Ride 2 (2019)
- Toronto — How the West Was Dumb (2021)
- Santa Claus — Slay Ride IV: Revenge of the Claus (2021)
- Loren Lipschitz — A Very Hellmark Christmas Special (2022)
As an understudy:
- Sir Harry Proctor-Gamble-Smythe — Indiana Smith and the Restaurant of Doom (2022)
- Mac McGuffin — Overture for an Undertaker (May 2024)
- Professor Savory Scapegoat — Harry 4gotter and the Pantry of the Secret Sauces (Oct 2025)
In revival:
- Baron Von Halen — Mission: Unpossible (2023)
- Newt Diamond — Murder at the Kit Kat Klub (2024)
The Mystery Theatre Unlimited, at various times, features:
Emeritus Members
Others Who Have Appeared with the Company
Last updated: October 16, 2025